So here I am in Boise, driving down Fairview, which is a super busy main arterial into the downtown area. (So busy that I was only able to get on it to inspect the distresses between 6-7 AM. I'd have gotten on earlier if the sun was up) and what to my wondering eyes should appear, but a miniature LCS, (and used book store). I went in.
Interesting. Total Android's Dungeon. Dingy, dark, and EVERY comic book was pre-bagged. Shades of 1995! Overheard a comment between the clerk (owner) and a customer, "Do comics still sell?"
"They're 80% of our business."
This amused me because 80% of his floor space was given over to used paperbacks. Hmmm?
I bought four books. Two from IDW and two from Image. I had never heard of any of them before.
They ALL were perfect manifestations of why comics have trouble pulling the casual reader. Each was part of some longer story... each a part of a story without providing a beginning nor an ending.... just a bunch of act two. And all were obviously a part of some large, complex story that the respective writers had worked out in great and loving detail in their heads... and probably should have written as a novel, rather then a comic book. All had sharp graphics, professional and contemporary cover design. All had seen an enormous amount of love and attention to detail in their execution.
I'll start with IDW.
Locke&Key by Joe Hill, Gabriel Rodriguez and Jay Fotos. This was the 6th of 13 issues. The art was careful and well detailed, and if not quite the sort of high energy line work I prefer, I recognize it was very professional. Its about some kind of body jumping demon, and given that its the middle of a story, not too hard to pick up on. They do provide a handy-dandy precis/intro on the inside front cover... but still, its the middle of a long story, and if you're going to hook people at this point, you need a catch. The art was professional, but not seductive enough.The hook in the story was, I guess, the mutilations. So daring. But not for me. Not world I care to re-visit.
Infestation by Abnett and Lanning, with art by David Messina and various helpers. Issue 2. This had more of a big two kind of feel to the art with the colorist dominating the linework, as has so often become the case these days. More careful, if staid, artwork. And even more pseudo-mysticism here with some kind of vampire-zombie mash-up/ secret organization and a big red guy with horns who wasn't Hellboy and managed to be utterly bland visually and in his personality. They seem intent of stopping some sort of hot chick bent on destroying four universes by becoming the same sort of combo vampire/zombie that evidently she is. Yeahhhh... no.
IMAGE
These were better, but ultimately suffered from the same sorts of problems.
Blue Estate by Victor Kalvachev predominately, with a couple of other writers and artists lending a hand. There's a beautiful painted cover that doesn't look like the artwork inside, although its by the same artist. The interior has the kind of quirky energetic art I favor and features imaginative color that doesn't overwhelm, and some memorable characters, or at least character designs. No mystical shit from what I can see. It seems to be about crime and sex and an inheritance. I might read another issue if I happened to see it again... on the other hand, its still only a few scenes of a story for $3.99. See more at their website www.BlueEstateComic.com
CarbonGrey by a whole bunch of people and I can't tell who is the driver, but this one I liked the best, although again, and more story for your 4 bux, but still only an episode. The painted interior art matched the cover and both were truly lovely. The digital lettering looked totally out of place and rather then puuling you into the story, it is distancing, reminding you that the images are paintings. I use digital lettering and its a godsend for me but it does have limitations and they are fully on display here. I was engaged and intrigued, but more than any other, this should have been a fantasy novel or video game. oh yes, its an alternate reality history of WW I with a quartet of (magical?) sisters engaged to protect the Kaiser.
I'd read the novel.
So. What have you read lately?
Showing posts with label readings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label readings. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 18, 2011
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Mercy Blade

And the second of my two vampire hunter romance action adventure books. I liked this one better. More action. More plot. the lead character is not in and of herself more interesting then the last one... or the Anita Blake characters for that matter. The characters have pretty interchangeable personalities. They invariably have some extraordinary powers that make them lethal to the bad supernaturals, and useful to he powerful (but good)ones. Sexually, they are good girls, or good girl wannabes who find themselves drawn into a web of romantic and sexual intrigue. These are, at bottom, romances... but Faith Hunter delivers on the promise of action that the other two authors mentioned keep to a minimum.
Friday, February 11, 2011
Blood Heat

Google Blood Heat, and one comes up with a lot of books not to mention other usages of the term. This is the one I just read. A year or two back I sampled Laural K Hamilton's Anita Blake, Vampire Slayer books. I found them to be about 70% conversations about relationships, 20% steamy explicit sex, and 10% action. I felt like I was reading in a thick soup. and after several of these, was ready for something more astringent.
Maria Lima's book tends to follow these tropes closely, except that the sex is not very explicit at all. The other tropes of this sort of dark urban fantasy, as the genre is called, all seemed to be in place. A feudal relationship between various clans of supernatural beings, vampires and werewolves being the most popular although other types of were creatures are assumed as well, establishes the basic culture, with vampires generally seen as being at the top of the hierarchy.
There is a strong(meaning a combat badass)female lead, who likes sex (often with multiple partners)a lot, is herself partnered with a bi-sexual Master of the City (a king vampire)who takes on the role of co-leader through this relationship, coupled with her own innate and potent set of magical skills.
I would point out that science fiction has a long tradition of galactic civilizations being conceived along feudal lines, Dune, anyone? And the ass-kicking female lead who can go mano a mano with with male antagonists is popular enough in superhero comic books. Both of these tropes contain dominance/submission themes that are popular in romance and pornography, and the pack structure of the werewolf clans overtly plays right into this.
As an aside, I wonder how many of these writers recognize that the wer term in werewolf is a cognate of the Latin vir, for man, as in virile. They tend to use it to mean animal shape-shifters, and it is convenient shorthand, but actually refers to the human component, rather than the beast, which their usage of the term suggests.
As a final note, I would add that most of these books are written by women, for women. ts a popular genre to judge by the shelf space and number of TV shows out there. next I'll be reading Faith Hunter's Mercy Blade as continue my research.
Friday, February 4, 2011
Classical Painting Atelier

Author Juliette Aristides even has a name that's made for this approach to painting instruction. Aristides is an advocate for a return to the atelier method of art instruction, wherein talented students work with a master painter, who passes on the secrets of the craft, and teaches painting, sculpture and drawing from life, developing in artists an acute eye for observation.
This of course is how it was done for centuries before the development of art instruction in universities. And it has very much the virtues of teaching and progressing in an organized, coherent fashion with new learning based on the old. University education can be very much a hop-scotch of learning, especially in an era of underfunding and overcrowding. Students have to get classes when they can.
While this approach can and has in he past led to academic straitjackets on what is acceptable in art, current methods can lead to a lack of craft and critical acumen. A balance, as always, is needed. Aristides' arguments that traditional subjects such as still life, portraiture and figure can be handled with an eye to the modern sensibility, and retain the power to evoke an emotional response is amply demonstrated through the choice of illustrations, which includes paintings by old masters with student work from her atelier.
This book is inspiring me to attempt painting again.
Thursday, February 3, 2011
Who Is Jake Ellis?
The following is posted verbatim from a thread I've started at Panel and Pixel.com
************
It seems to me that we don't talk enough about the good comics we've read. Mia culpa, I don't read a lot. When I was much, much younger, I marveled at the Jack Kirby's of the world who confessed that they didn't regularly read comics. Impossible! Granted, artists can better get away with this than writers who have plot threads to pick up (assuming you do WFH). But at 57, I get it. And no, I'm not going to try and explain it. That isn't the point of this thread.
The point is, I do pick up comics from time to time, and I do look for things that have some point of interest. One so rarely gets a complete story in a pamphlet comic, that its almost useless to purchase based on that. But I'm an artist, and I do get excited when I see art... and more particularly, storytelling that works for me.
So the rule for this thread is point to a comic you read that was worth a look see, and explain why. No pointing to comics created by any of the regulars here. We know Marv is an eminence gris and Jimmie is a prodigy. We recognize that Russell has more talent in his pinkie than Michalangleo put into God's index finger. JAQ is a legendary wit and Derek is Proust. Jason and PJ are the new Stan and Lee.
What else is out there that we can learn from?
So the other day I was thumbing through the funny books at Comics Relief in Berkeley, enhancing the value of mere comic by dog-earring the pages. The stuff from the Big two features some impressive drawing, and absolutely amazing coloring. The development of digital coloring has fueled a style of drawing that is very open and sparely rendered. I firmly believe that colorists should be getting a hell of a lot more credit. They are turning forms and establishing mood in ways that inkers used to do. But the visual storytelling is uniformly flabby.
Enter, Who Is Jake Ellis? by Nathan Edmundson and Tonci Zonjic. The immediate impression is Alex Toth in his marker pen, Torpedo, Bravo for Adventure. Very spare drawing, complemented by equally spare coloring. Not monotone, but coloring is is only moderately used for turning forms. The writing is elegant... just enough to carry the story and characterizations without bombast. better than Toth's writing by a margin.
But its in the visual storytelling where this book really stands out. Staging, camera angles, just the right details, compositional variety... all of these keep the story moving along at a sprightly pace. If you want to see what I consider to be an an engaging, involving way to tell stories, check this out.
************
It seems to me that we don't talk enough about the good comics we've read. Mia culpa, I don't read a lot. When I was much, much younger, I marveled at the Jack Kirby's of the world who confessed that they didn't regularly read comics. Impossible! Granted, artists can better get away with this than writers who have plot threads to pick up (assuming you do WFH). But at 57, I get it. And no, I'm not going to try and explain it. That isn't the point of this thread.
The point is, I do pick up comics from time to time, and I do look for things that have some point of interest. One so rarely gets a complete story in a pamphlet comic, that its almost useless to purchase based on that. But I'm an artist, and I do get excited when I see art... and more particularly, storytelling that works for me.
So the rule for this thread is point to a comic you read that was worth a look see, and explain why. No pointing to comics created by any of the regulars here. We know Marv is an eminence gris and Jimmie is a prodigy. We recognize that Russell has more talent in his pinkie than Michalangleo put into God's index finger. JAQ is a legendary wit and Derek is Proust. Jason and PJ are the new Stan and Lee.
What else is out there that we can learn from?
So the other day I was thumbing through the funny books at Comics Relief in Berkeley, enhancing the value of mere comic by dog-earring the pages. The stuff from the Big two features some impressive drawing, and absolutely amazing coloring. The development of digital coloring has fueled a style of drawing that is very open and sparely rendered. I firmly believe that colorists should be getting a hell of a lot more credit. They are turning forms and establishing mood in ways that inkers used to do. But the visual storytelling is uniformly flabby.
Enter, Who Is Jake Ellis? by Nathan Edmundson and Tonci Zonjic. The immediate impression is Alex Toth in his marker pen, Torpedo, Bravo for Adventure. Very spare drawing, complemented by equally spare coloring. Not monotone, but coloring is is only moderately used for turning forms. The writing is elegant... just enough to carry the story and characterizations without bombast. better than Toth's writing by a margin.
But its in the visual storytelling where this book really stands out. Staging, camera angles, just the right details, compositional variety... all of these keep the story moving along at a sprightly pace. If you want to see what I consider to be an an engaging, involving way to tell stories, check this out.
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
How NOT To...

Most of my posts have been about my comics work, self-promotion really. But I also try to comment about books I've read, and the dearth of posts on this subject reveals how little in the way of long form reading I've been doing this past year.
I got this book, How To Live Safely In A Science Fictional Universe as a Christmas gift from C, and its one I had looked at previously and thought sounded promising. Clever title, and the central conceit of time travel as tense had promise. The author introduced several characters, or at least character concepts that appeared likely as sources of humor or insight.They provided neither.
The book reads at a brisk pace. Yet it took me several weeks to get 80% of the way through the book. Some of this I attribute to my own malaise about reading novels these days. I am spending a good deal my intellectual capital on short for reading... mostly on my computer.
But in truth, I did something I almost never do. I quit. I had maybe less than 50 pages of reading left to do, and I put the book down and said to myself, "No more."
I even flipped through to the end to see what happened, and evidently something did happen, but I couldn't bring myself to care about how it happened. I just couldn't care about the central character, and I was tired of waiting for some plot development.
I simply got worn out listening to the narrator whine about his relationship with his father. As with the last book I read, Big Machine either the author was not in control of his metaphors and themes or they were too deep for me.
Frankly, if a book can't engage me 20% of the way in, I should have an obligation to finish it. 80% seems like I gave it altogether too much credit. Going in, it seemed like a book I would like. Somebody liked it... they published it. C plans to read it. Perhaps it will suit her more than me. I hope so.
Thursday, December 30, 2010
Big Machine

I was in the habit for a while of posting short reviews and commentaries on books I've been reading but I haven't been reading much of late. Took me a month to get through this, not because its bad or hard, but just because I'm reading briefly at night before bed.
Good enough, imaginative, lots of symbolic stuff going on. I'm not sure if the author was entirely in control of his metaphors and symbols, or I'm just too dense to track them. Either way, enjoyable enough urban fantasy to read and be unconcerned about all that deeper jazz.
Saturday, July 31, 2010
Of Dragon Tattoos
I got Stieg Larsson's The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo as a Father's Day gift. I had seen the Millenium books at work, but had never really heard anything about them prior to that. They're bestsellers, which is probably why I hadn't heard of them. I don't keep track of the Man-Booker Prize or the National Book Awards either.
I had some other reading to do first, and by the time I got to it, I was a little burnt out. I read the prologue and thought it was engaging enough, but set the book aside for a few days. I finally got going on it and thought, well, that it moved slowly, and Larsson spent a lot of time describing the backstory of each character he introduced. Y'know the old "show, don't tell" dictum? Well, he tells. And tells. And tells. In other words, I didn't think the writing, as such, was all that great.
But the story kept me in it, I'll give it that. It develops slowly. The big action climax occurs more than 100 pages before the story is over. Larsson spends the rest of it tieing up all the other loose ends. Nevertheless, by the end of it, I wanted to read the other two books. I liked the characters and world he created.
I picked up The Girl Who Played with Fire and read through that fairly quickly. I had been told that it was "not as good as the first." No, I suppose not. This book was also slow to develop, told more than showed, the villains were cartoonish, it was told from many more points of view than that of the two protagonists, who never even spent any time together until the final pages, and almost never even communicated with each other!
And by the end, it was clear that this was really the first half of a novel. Oh, it resolved the main dilemma well enough, but left plenty of loose threads waiting to be picked up in the next novel The Girl Who kicked the Hornet's Nest, which, judging by the preview at the back, picks up directly from the end of the second book.
It looks to me like Larsson had one book in mind, and by the time he finished, was so hooked in by his own characters that he wanted to write more, and plotted out a longer tale based on backstory he had developed but not included in the first book. there are a few clues... but they may have been added in after he finished the trio. They were all submitted for publication at once after all. I've no doubt that Larsson, had he lived, would have continued the series, especially given how popular its become.
I haven't read the third book yet. Its still in hardcover and I'll probably wait for the paperback.
The English language titles are more colorful than the Swedish ones. The first was called Men Who Hate Women, I believe, and it certainly spells out one of the themes of the book and gives a taste of the somewhat heavy handed approach Larsson takes to all things. You won't mistake his intentions.
Will I go see the movies? The Swedish versions might be interesting and boring at once. An American version will star Daniel Craig as Michael Blomkvist, which had me groaning. I like Craig well enough (unlike C who can't stand him) but I think he's too buff and hyper-masculine for Blomkvist, who reads to me like more of a regular guy, reasonable fit and with a gift for attracting woman. The more it sits with me, the more I think that Craig can pull it off though. He's a pretty good actor I think, just too hunky.
As of now,they apparently are still testing actresses for Lisbeth Salander. I saw Ellen Page in Inception yesterday and thought that she would be a fine choice. She's very small, pretty but not too pretty, and still looks to be about 15 years old, although at 23, she's the same age as Salander in the first book. Her persona seems rather low key and even dry, which suits Salander, and I read that she was considered but is not on the final list. they will probably settle on someone who is glum and pouty.
I can't believe they considered Scarlett Johansson at any point, but it was on the Interweb, so it must be true.
I had some other reading to do first, and by the time I got to it, I was a little burnt out. I read the prologue and thought it was engaging enough, but set the book aside for a few days. I finally got going on it and thought, well, that it moved slowly, and Larsson spent a lot of time describing the backstory of each character he introduced. Y'know the old "show, don't tell" dictum? Well, he tells. And tells. And tells. In other words, I didn't think the writing, as such, was all that great.
But the story kept me in it, I'll give it that. It develops slowly. The big action climax occurs more than 100 pages before the story is over. Larsson spends the rest of it tieing up all the other loose ends. Nevertheless, by the end of it, I wanted to read the other two books. I liked the characters and world he created.
I picked up The Girl Who Played with Fire and read through that fairly quickly. I had been told that it was "not as good as the first." No, I suppose not. This book was also slow to develop, told more than showed, the villains were cartoonish, it was told from many more points of view than that of the two protagonists, who never even spent any time together until the final pages, and almost never even communicated with each other!
And by the end, it was clear that this was really the first half of a novel. Oh, it resolved the main dilemma well enough, but left plenty of loose threads waiting to be picked up in the next novel The Girl Who kicked the Hornet's Nest, which, judging by the preview at the back, picks up directly from the end of the second book.
It looks to me like Larsson had one book in mind, and by the time he finished, was so hooked in by his own characters that he wanted to write more, and plotted out a longer tale based on backstory he had developed but not included in the first book. there are a few clues... but they may have been added in after he finished the trio. They were all submitted for publication at once after all. I've no doubt that Larsson, had he lived, would have continued the series, especially given how popular its become.
I haven't read the third book yet. Its still in hardcover and I'll probably wait for the paperback.
The English language titles are more colorful than the Swedish ones. The first was called Men Who Hate Women, I believe, and it certainly spells out one of the themes of the book and gives a taste of the somewhat heavy handed approach Larsson takes to all things. You won't mistake his intentions.
Will I go see the movies? The Swedish versions might be interesting and boring at once. An American version will star Daniel Craig as Michael Blomkvist, which had me groaning. I like Craig well enough (unlike C who can't stand him) but I think he's too buff and hyper-masculine for Blomkvist, who reads to me like more of a regular guy, reasonable fit and with a gift for attracting woman. The more it sits with me, the more I think that Craig can pull it off though. He's a pretty good actor I think, just too hunky.
As of now,they apparently are still testing actresses for Lisbeth Salander. I saw Ellen Page in Inception yesterday and thought that she would be a fine choice. She's very small, pretty but not too pretty, and still looks to be about 15 years old, although at 23, she's the same age as Salander in the first book. Her persona seems rather low key and even dry, which suits Salander, and I read that she was considered but is not on the final list. they will probably settle on someone who is glum and pouty.
I can't believe they considered Scarlett Johansson at any point, but it was on the Interweb, so it must be true.
Sunday, June 27, 2010
Finch

By Jeff Vandermeer.
Once again I wander off the plantation with a weird fantasy novel described on the cover as "fungal noir" and "Steampunk delerium". Its another crime story. This time in a city covered in fungus. The bad guys are mushrooms. But that's not what put me off at first. It was the writing. Which featured altogether too many sentence fragments. As in.
Finch sat up. Couldn't see it. Just heard its breathing. Which was worse.
Drove me nuts. Until eventually the story picked up some steam. Began using less. Of that sort of thing. Or I stopped. Noticing it so much.
The city BTW is called Ambergris and appears in several of Vandermeer's books. the word sounded familiar so I did Wiki search:
Ambergris (Ambra grisea, Ambre gris, ambergrease, or grey amber) is a solid, waxy, flammable substance of a dull gray or blackish color produced in the digestive system of and regurgitated by sperm whales.
Freshly produced ambergris has a marine, fecal odor. However, as it ages, it acquires a sweet, earthy scent commonly likened to the fragrance of rubbing alcohol without the vaporous chemical astringency. The principal historical use of ambergris was as a fixative in perfumery, though it has now been largely displaced by synthetics.
Sunday, June 20, 2010
Wide Sargasso Sea

I read this as part of a reading group that C initiated. Its highly regarded but I found it a bit vague for my taste... or maybe it was just not what I'm looking for at the moment. I found myself slogging through it.
Oh well, I'm not sorry i read it, now that's its finished and there are more books out there to be read.
Sunday, June 13, 2010
The City & The City

By China Mieville (pronounced me-AH-vil).
Mieville tends to write about cities... weird cities and their even stranger inhabitants. By his standards, Beszel and Ul Qoma are pretty normal cities located somewhere on the south-eastern edges of Europe. What is unique is that these two independent city/nations largely occupy the same bit of turf and in many places overlap and yet remain invisible to each other.
Through an act of psychological will, the citizens of each city "unsee" the other city and its citizens and each remains strictly within its own boundaries. It is possible to go to the other city, if you have a passport and use the proper gate, but of course, once there, you must unsee your own city.
The story is a police procedural told from the perspective of Inspector Tyador Borlu of Beszel's Extreme Crime Squad. He's investigating the murder of a young woman and must, no surprise here, cross over to Ul Qoma to solve it.
In Mieville's skillful hands, this central conceit of unseeing your neighbor allows the book to function as a kind of meditation on how we all embrace the illusions of our preferred social realities.
Thursday, June 3, 2010
Cradle to Cradle part 06
Rather then end this on a down note, I shall give a re-cap of the final points McDonough and Braungart make on the road to a cradle to cradle society. They do seem to recognize the complexity of the journey, and acknowledge that it can be taken in steps.
Five steps to Eco-Effectiveness (in brief):
1_ Get "free of" known culprits. That is, stop using stuff we know is poison, and much of what we suspect as well. This is no solution in itself, but a necessary first step.
2_ Follow informed personal preferences. There is a lot out there, and as designers we can't know about it all. But educate yourself as best you can and take your best shot at getting it right.
3_Create a passive positive list. Find the things that are healthful and prefer to use them. Its not enough to get rid of the known bad because other bad things can still be in the mix. Prefer to use only the good things as much as possible.
4_Activate the positive list. Didn't I just go over that?
5_Reinvent. Its not enough to simply go about things the old way, but using new ingredients. Think of new ways of doing things and new technologies.
The authors are very positive about the prospects of new technologies solving old problems and in this they are not alone. But it is not enough to imagine that it will simply happen on its own, as some have proposed. It has to happen within the confines of a better way of imagimng the outcome, and a recognition that the Law of Unintended Consequences still holds.
It seems unlikely to me that there will ever be perfect solutions to any given circumstances, but there can be better ones and this book offers a vision for finding one.
Five steps to Eco-Effectiveness (in brief):
1_ Get "free of" known culprits. That is, stop using stuff we know is poison, and much of what we suspect as well. This is no solution in itself, but a necessary first step.
2_ Follow informed personal preferences. There is a lot out there, and as designers we can't know about it all. But educate yourself as best you can and take your best shot at getting it right.
3_Create a passive positive list. Find the things that are healthful and prefer to use them. Its not enough to get rid of the known bad because other bad things can still be in the mix. Prefer to use only the good things as much as possible.
4_Activate the positive list. Didn't I just go over that?
5_Reinvent. Its not enough to simply go about things the old way, but using new ingredients. Think of new ways of doing things and new technologies.
The authors are very positive about the prospects of new technologies solving old problems and in this they are not alone. But it is not enough to imagine that it will simply happen on its own, as some have proposed. It has to happen within the confines of a better way of imagimng the outcome, and a recognition that the Law of Unintended Consequences still holds.
It seems unlikely to me that there will ever be perfect solutions to any given circumstances, but there can be better ones and this book offers a vision for finding one.
Cradle to Cradle part 05
The other part of upcycling involves technological waste and this seems to me to be much more challenging. The key term used here is that of a "product of service." Thus you don't buy a car or shoes or computer, you lease them through their useful lives, and when you are finished the manufacturer reclaims them and disassembles them for re-use as a high end product.
The challenges to accomplish this are mind-boggling. Here the authors blithely assume that it will be cheaper to re-use materials rather then using virgin materials. In the current world, this is very often not the case. Plastics can be re-cycled, but it is generally not economic to do so. Re-cycling glass is much cheaper. The authors speak of the challenges of smelting steel and keeping other metals and materials out so that it does not have to be re-used for a "lesser" purpose, having lost some of its integrity.
So designing products and product distribution in such a way that makes them inexpensively reclaimable, reusable... forever, is their goal. Given the seemingly infinite complexity of the natural world and our shallow grasp of it, designing an economic/manufacturing/distribution system to match it would appear hopeless.
When I look at the recycling bins and what people through into them with all the best intentions, but little willingness to simply read and grasp the instrcutions written on the bins, I despair.
Not that we shouldn't try.
The challenges to accomplish this are mind-boggling. Here the authors blithely assume that it will be cheaper to re-use materials rather then using virgin materials. In the current world, this is very often not the case. Plastics can be re-cycled, but it is generally not economic to do so. Re-cycling glass is much cheaper. The authors speak of the challenges of smelting steel and keeping other metals and materials out so that it does not have to be re-used for a "lesser" purpose, having lost some of its integrity.
So designing products and product distribution in such a way that makes them inexpensively reclaimable, reusable... forever, is their goal. Given the seemingly infinite complexity of the natural world and our shallow grasp of it, designing an economic/manufacturing/distribution system to match it would appear hopeless.
When I look at the recycling bins and what people through into them with all the best intentions, but little willingness to simply read and grasp the instrcutions written on the bins, I despair.
Not that we shouldn't try.
Cradle to Cradle part 04
UPcycling, returning products to a useful life over and over again, is a concept that McDonough and Braungart see as key in their conception. REcycling is not enough. Recycling is down-cycling and ultimately leads to the dump... the process is simply delayed. It still conforms to the paradigm of cradle to grave that the authors seek to change.
One half of the cradle to cradle conception is bio-metabolism. This one is easy enough to understand, and seems most immediately do-able. It would seem that nature can filter and re-use biological waste if it is properly returned and devoid of excessive poisons. Even here, the use of wetlands and plant life to filter sewage and manufacturing bio-waste is proposed and examples given.
I had to chuckle though. Contaminated biological waste is known to cause genetic damage to wildlife. Might it not do the same to plant life if used as wetlands and swales to cleanse water? Perhaps plants are not as important as animals... although I occasional rail in a kidding way that when a cow is milked, the cow remains unharmed, but when soy milk is used... well, millions of soy beans gave their lives for that.
But we are animals and consume other life to sustain ourselves. We don't photosynthesize.
One half of the cradle to cradle conception is bio-metabolism. This one is easy enough to understand, and seems most immediately do-able. It would seem that nature can filter and re-use biological waste if it is properly returned and devoid of excessive poisons. Even here, the use of wetlands and plant life to filter sewage and manufacturing bio-waste is proposed and examples given.
I had to chuckle though. Contaminated biological waste is known to cause genetic damage to wildlife. Might it not do the same to plant life if used as wetlands and swales to cleanse water? Perhaps plants are not as important as animals... although I occasional rail in a kidding way that when a cow is milked, the cow remains unharmed, but when soy milk is used... well, millions of soy beans gave their lives for that.
But we are animals and consume other life to sustain ourselves. We don't photosynthesize.
Cradle to Cradle part 03
So I finished the book last night, and overall I find it to represent an inspiring, if unfinished, concept. And inspirational is what the book aims for... it certainly doesn't offer many specifics as guide posts for achieving its aims. But these aims are ambitious and involve a lot of deep thinking and restructuring of the manufacturing process to be achievable.
One of their fundamental concepts is expressed as "waste equals food." The idea is that in nature, everything gets fully recycled/consumed as the nutrients/food for the next cycle of growth.
Hmmm, borrowing from Nietzsche's Apollonian/Dionysian dialectic, Camille Paglia, in Sexual Personae, speaks of Man's fear of Nature's amoral consumption/destruction and effervescent growth/birth. In her description, Western culture equates women with Nature, and men created civilization, art, government, technology, as a way to wall off Nature. I have taken the concept as a basis for my understanding of Horror as a literary genre, as expresses in an earlier essay here.
Of course, Paglia was speaking of art, and McDonough and Braungart are focused much more on technology... although, joy, fun, expressions of beauty are added as important values in their conception. Paglia also describes ancient Egypt as having attained the most perfect synthesis of the Apollonian/Dionysian poles, seeing them as unified, rather then as opposites to bounce back and forth between as Western civilization has done.
And something like that is what McDonough and Braungart seem to be seeking.
One of their fundamental concepts is expressed as "waste equals food." The idea is that in nature, everything gets fully recycled/consumed as the nutrients/food for the next cycle of growth.
Hmmm, borrowing from Nietzsche's Apollonian/Dionysian dialectic, Camille Paglia, in Sexual Personae, speaks of Man's fear of Nature's amoral consumption/destruction and effervescent growth/birth. In her description, Western culture equates women with Nature, and men created civilization, art, government, technology, as a way to wall off Nature. I have taken the concept as a basis for my understanding of Horror as a literary genre, as expresses in an earlier essay here.
Of course, Paglia was speaking of art, and McDonough and Braungart are focused much more on technology... although, joy, fun, expressions of beauty are added as important values in their conception. Paglia also describes ancient Egypt as having attained the most perfect synthesis of the Apollonian/Dionysian poles, seeing them as unified, rather then as opposites to bounce back and forth between as Western civilization has done.
And something like that is what McDonough and Braungart seem to be seeking.
Sunday, May 30, 2010
Cradle to Cradle part 02
Chapter two continues the analysis and chapter three begins describing solutions. The authors describe industry and environment as seeing themselves as antagonists. Fair enough. They are seeking a new paradigm that sees these as collaborators, where industry is inherently renewable and nourishing.
And most interesting to me is that they see this as a design issue. Regulation is required to the depredations of industry, whereas a well designed system would require no regulation because the benefits would be inherently profitable and well as healthy.
I have prattled to friends in the past about good work flow design and how it could be implemented at my work places. I've described it as "designing work flow so that people do things the way they want to, and it gives you the results you want." When you can effectively do this, you can save yourself all kinds of management headaches.
So seeing this as a design issue, as McDonough and Braungart do, certainly appeals to me.
And most interesting to me is that they see this as a design issue. Regulation is required to the depredations of industry, whereas a well designed system would require no regulation because the benefits would be inherently profitable and well as healthy.
I have prattled to friends in the past about good work flow design and how it could be implemented at my work places. I've described it as "designing work flow so that people do things the way they want to, and it gives you the results you want." When you can effectively do this, you can save yourself all kinds of management headaches.
So seeing this as a design issue, as McDonough and Braungart do, certainly appeals to me.
Cradle to Cradle part 01

Subtitled "Remaking the Way We Make Things".
I have just started reading Cradle to Cradle based on the recommendation of an architect friend of mine. Researching it, I recalled that the first named author, Wm. McDonough, was positively mentioned in a class I had previously taken.
I'm only just a little ways in, so I dare not make too many assumptions about where the authors (McDonough and Micheal Braungart) are going, but suspicions and cautions do crop up during the early reading.
Will this be simply a Utopian wish fantasy about living with nature? Is the agenda implausibly radical? Will it account for the fact that economics will invariably be a powerful driver for any achievable aims? I don't know the answers to these questions yet, but I'll be reading on to find out.
The premise of Cradle to Cradle, is that the "Reduce, reuse, recycle" mantra of environmentalists is insufficient to stem the degradation of the world we live in, and eventually the quality of our lives. Down-cycling waste only slows the "cradle to grave" creation and consumption approach that is built into our economy and lifestyles.
Citing the back cover because I haven't reached this point in the book yet; the authors propose a "waste equals food" concept that designs products from the outset to become the "nutrients" of new products. Hmmm... it sounds like a system without entropy. Can there be absolutely no waste? At this point I doubt it, and suspect that what the authors will propose is more like a further slowing of decay... not that that's a bad thing.
But in the big picture, the earth is not a closed system. It is driven by energy from the sun, so the metaphor of infinite ssutainablity falls aprt here. And of course in the even larger picture, we don't yet know whether to expect the eventual heat death of the Universe, or its rebound into a new Big Bang.
Of course all of that is far outside of the scope of sustainable living as we mean it today. For our purposes, there may be much of value in what McDonough and Braungart propose. Stay tuned as I read on.
Friday, May 28, 2010
I read Lolita.
Of course we are all scandalized to know that the monster Humbert Humbert is in love with the barely pubescent nymphet Dolores Haze, called Dolly, Lo, Lola and for Hum, his own Lolita.Beyond that, I didn't know what to expect. What I found was a story about love. Rapturous love. Obsessive, destructive love. Love at first sight. Love that derails Dolly's childhood and twists Humbert from observation to action to crime.
Nabokov never panders. The sex is deftly, delicately, discretely handled. The inner workings of Humbert's obsession are likewise pinned and described as delicately as the butterflies Nabokov hunted every summer. Lo is seen from a distance, through the prism of Humbert's rapture, and only slowly reveals herself.
The early chapters give you Humbert circling his desired object, followed by the long ramble of travel with Hum and his imagined "daughter as wife". The book closes with the delirium of Humbert's inevitable loss and the impossibility of its recapture.
Humbert's love does great damage to many people, but in the end, the reader is left with no doubt that he did indeed love his Lolita as deeply and as poorly as any love in literature.
Worth a read.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)